{
  "id": "ffdf83e6-31a8-42f5-b94e-fb8a1f664b28",
  "label": "Who was responsible for the killing of Hind Rajab?",
  "url": "/question/who-was-responsible-for-the-killing-of-hind-rajab--ffdf83e6",
  "lens": "log-odds@1",
  "lensName": "Evidence-weighted",
  "asof": null,
  "exclusive": true,
  "promotedAt": "2026-09-08T18:01:02.298Z",
  "updatedAt": "2026-10-22T10:02:03.574Z",
  "subjects": [
    {
      "id": "2f998726-273e-4daa-be7e-b2f060aef304",
      "kind": "entity",
      "label": "Hind Rajab"
    }
  ],
  "branches": [
    {
      "claimId": "b69b491b-fabb-4269-9d30-da7514238db3",
      "label": "Hind Rajab was a five-year-old Palestinian girl in the Gaza Strip who was killed by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) during the Gaza war.",
      "url": "/claim/hind-rajab-was-a-five-year-old-palestinian-girl-in-the-gaza-strip-who--b69b491b",
      "share": null,
      "belief": null,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": null,
      "supports": [
        {
          "claimId": "696bb9cd-3578-4208-bb2a-8acba36cb190",
          "label": "Both Hind Rajab and the two Red Crescent ambulance workers Yusuf al‑Zeino and Ahmed al‑Madhoun were found dead on 10 February 2024 after an Israeli withdrawal.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "weak",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "86177295-7d0d-4a3c-86fc-a25daa6526be",
          "label": "United Nations Human Rights Council independent experts stated that Hind Rajab's killing might amount to a war crime.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "5fa14fd5-119a-4817-843c-552302a60f82",
          "label": "Dr Helen McCue calls out Israel for what she describes as reproductive genocide in Gaza.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "weak",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": false,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "d5ad1b56-7871-4c97-98ec-68a80c451e4d",
              "label": "Israel is committing reproductive genocide."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "challenges": [],
      "firings": [],
      "worldsWith": 0,
      "worldsTotal": 0
    },
    {
      "claimId": "54e204ec-50c6-4432-9de8-677bc586c75a",
      "label": "On 29 January 2024, Hind Rajab and her family were fleeing Gaza City when their vehicle was shelled by the IDF, killing her uncle, aunt and three cousins.",
      "url": "/claim/on-29-january-2024-hind-rajab-and-her-family-were-fleeing-gaza-city--54e204ec",
      "share": null,
      "belief": null,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": null,
      "supports": [
        {
          "claimId": "5f130e90-6460-4400-9459-be05f25dd6ce",
          "label": "Justice For All submitted a case to the ICC charging the IDF with multiple war crimes for the killing of Hind Rajab on 13 February 2024.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "a3abd588-fcc9-4ebc-b41f-f409acaf5755",
          "label": "The cousin Layan Hamadeh later also was killed and Hind Rajab was left stranded in the vehicle for hours on the phone while paramedics attempted to rescue her.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "challenges": [],
      "firings": [],
      "worldsWith": 0,
      "worldsTotal": 0
    },
    {
      "claimId": "fcc64211-913b-470e-ad31-06821281031b",
      "label": "The Hind Rajab Foundation claimed it had identified Lieutenant Colonel Beni Aharon of the 401st Armored Brigade as the commander responsible for Hind Rajab's killing and filed a war crimes complaint with the ICC on 3 May 2025.",
      "url": "/claim/the-hind-rajab-foundation-claimed-it-had-identified-lieutenant-colonel--fcc64211",
      "share": null,
      "belief": null,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": null,
      "supports": [],
      "challenges": [],
      "firings": [],
      "worldsWith": 0,
      "worldsTotal": 0
    },
    {
      "claimId": "380a8853-6bad-4f87-b9f4-c81bb643a371",
      "label": "The Red Crescent blamed Israel for deliberately targeting the ambulance crew.",
      "url": "/claim/the-red-crescent-blamed-israel-for-deliberately-targeting-the-ambulance--380a8853",
      "share": null,
      "belief": null,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": null,
      "supports": [
        {
          "claimId": "899c95d8-73b2-421c-a506-8e6e62ca6bbf",
          "label": "Forensic Architecture investigation concluded that an Israeli tank had also likely attacked the Red Crescent ambulance that came for Hind Rajab.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "strong",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "challenges": [],
      "firings": [
        {
          "claimId": "a80ee6dd-d1a2-4264-bf76-10f627f02b29",
          "label": "Israel deliberately targeted the ambulance crew.",
          "scheme": "expert-testimony",
          "version": "v1",
          "premises": [
            {
              "id": "380a8853-6bad-4f87-b9f4-c81bb643a371",
              "label": "The Red Crescent blamed Israel for deliberately targeting the ambulance crew."
            }
          ],
          "criticalQuestions": [
            {
              "id": "f211222a-1de8-4b33-81aa-1969fb4a1231",
              "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "58e27cd8-1f58-47b4-8197-9ce120a448e8",
              "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "0a39d1f7-30e4-48fa-81c9-63beb5c7daf0",
              "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
              "status": "open"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "worldsWith": 0,
      "worldsTotal": 0
    },
    {
      "claimId": "8aa0210b-12bd-45ca-93d5-bf15b0258f19",
      "label": "The UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry report in September 2025 concluded that Israel committed genocide in Gaza and included Hind Rajab's killing as an example.",
      "url": "/claim/the-un-independent-international-commission-of-inquiry-report-in--8aa0210b",
      "share": null,
      "belief": null,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": null,
      "supports": [
        {
          "claimId": "5fa14fd5-119a-4817-843c-552302a60f82",
          "label": "Dr Helen McCue calls out Israel for what she describes as reproductive genocide in Gaza.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": false,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "d5ad1b56-7871-4c97-98ec-68a80c451e4d",
              "label": "Israel is committing reproductive genocide."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "challenges": [],
      "firings": [],
      "worldsWith": 0,
      "worldsTotal": 0
    },
    {
      "claimId": "0e97b721-1d4c-4ddb-ba68-be59a99a6409",
      "label": "The Washington Post and Sky News investigations, relying on satellite imagery and visual evidence, concluded that a number of Israeli tanks were present and one had likely fired 335 rounds on the car that Hind Rajab and her family had been in.",
      "url": "/claim/the-washington-post-and-sky-news-investigations-relying-on-satellite--0e97b721",
      "share": null,
      "belief": null,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": null,
      "supports": [
        {
          "claimId": "21d48525-787c-45d2-9353-b03358f60016",
          "label": "Al Jazeera investigation found three Israeli tanks were in the vicinity of Hind Rajab's family vehicle at the time of the attack.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "448ed81b-7215-4dc4-961b-a1aacc7fea1c",
          "label": "Clock Tower X, hired by the Israeli government, created websites that posted baseless theories blaming crossfire or Palestinian fighters for Hind Rajab's killing.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "7c56b264-f5b6-49b1-92c8-35e1dcd2b397",
          "label": "On 19 August 2026, the Israeli Defense Force announced that they had launched a criminal investigation into Hind Rajab's death.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "ced81e5c-c972-4dc6-98f5-0f3900c2a024",
          "label": "Shell fragments of an American-made M830A1 projectile were found at the site of the bombed Red Crescent ambulance.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "strong",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "challenges": [
        {
          "claimId": "f7b710f6-7492-4f33-b06f-ae2daf629562",
          "label": "Israel claimed that there were not any troops present in the neighborhood and denied carrying out the attack.",
          "direction": "challenges",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "weak",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
              "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "firings": [
        {
          "claimId": "f416fbc8-c648-4afc-91eb-2080f6d58376",
          "label": "A number of Israeli tanks were present and one of them likely fired 335 rounds at the car carrying Hind Rajab and her family.",
          "scheme": "expert-testimony",
          "version": "v1",
          "premises": [
            {
              "id": "0e97b721-1d4c-4ddb-ba68-be59a99a6409",
              "label": "The Washington Post and Sky News investigations, relying on satellite imagery and visual evidence, concluded that a number of Israeli tanks were present and one had likely fired 335 rounds on the car that Hind Rajab and her family had been in."
            }
          ],
          "criticalQuestions": [
            {
              "id": "718c67fe-99c7-4a97-9b1f-f4ce604360b8",
              "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "313478ab-921e-4bfc-8ef0-77fb104bf645",
              "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "c29ec847-8a44-4c25-bbdd-d6ec71b96585",
              "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
              "status": "open"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "worldsWith": 0,
      "worldsTotal": 0
    }
  ],
  "residual": {
    "share": null,
    "answers": 6,
    "spark": []
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "3acb66b6-998b-4bcd-8216-3e54e515b9c9",
      "kind": "source",
      "label": "death of a five-year old Palestinian girl by Israeli Army gunfire during the Israel-Gaza war"
    },
    {
      "id": "d5ad1b56-7871-4c97-98ec-68a80c451e4d",
      "kind": "source",
      "label": "Israel is committing reproductive genocide."
    }
  ],
  "narratives": [],
  "openCriticalQuestions": [
    {
      "id": "f211222a-1de8-4b33-81aa-1969fb4a1231",
      "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "Israel deliberately targeted the ambulance crew.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "58e27cd8-1f58-47b4-8197-9ce120a448e8",
      "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "Israel deliberately targeted the ambulance crew.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "0a39d1f7-30e4-48fa-81c9-63beb5c7daf0",
      "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "Israel deliberately targeted the ambulance crew.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "718c67fe-99c7-4a97-9b1f-f4ce604360b8",
      "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "A number of Israeli tanks were present and one of them likely fired 335 rounds at the car carrying Hind Rajab and her family.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "313478ab-921e-4bfc-8ef0-77fb104bf645",
      "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "A number of Israeli tanks were present and one of them likely fired 335 rounds at the car carrying Hind Rajab and her family.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "c29ec847-8a44-4c25-bbdd-d6ec71b96585",
      "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "A number of Israeli tanks were present and one of them likely fired 335 rounds at the car carrying Hind Rajab and her family.",
      "inferences": 1
    }
  ],
  "honesty": "Shares are belief under the named lens, computed from evidence — never assigned. Quote the residual with the share; leading is not proven; repetition never moves a number."
}