{
  "id": "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6",
  "label": "Who is the detainee shown in the photo?",
  "url": "/question/who-is-the-detainee-shown-in-the-photo--52cd84ca",
  "lens": "log-odds@1",
  "lensName": "Evidence-weighted",
  "asof": null,
  "exclusive": true,
  "promotedAt": "2026-07-21T01:59:52.862Z",
  "updatedAt": "2026-07-21T02:10:19.268Z",
  "subjects": [
    {
      "id": "b63c3e6b-1707-4ad7-9398-997651f8db5c",
      "kind": "entity",
      "label": "detainees"
    },
    {
      "id": "61488585-2216-4852-a1ed-4ef6165ea3ea",
      "kind": "entity",
      "label": "photo of bound Palestinian detainee"
    }
  ],
  "branches": [
    {
      "claimId": "e451f07d-7718-4c3a-b6d8-90fc17d74c11",
      "label": "Rana Abu Nasser says the photo shows her son Osama.",
      "url": "/claim/rana-abu-nasser-says-the-photo-shows-her-son-osama--e451f07d",
      "share": 0.11734000396040263,
      "belief": 0.1192,
      "dormant": false,
      "profile": {
        "cq": {
          "open": 0,
          "favorable": 0,
          "unfavorable": 0
        },
        "legs": 0,
        "shape": "supported",
        "sources": 1,
        "challenges": 0,
        "restatements": 0,
        "contestedTime": false,
        "derivationDepth": 0,
        "supportingClaims": 1
      },
      "supports": [
        {
          "claimId": "7b5626d9-6f90-4db4-8f39-cc65ae816ed1",
          "label": "Osama was seized with his one‑year‑old son in March near the yellow line marking Israeli military control in Gaza.",
          "direction": "supports",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "df50e329-62a9-455c-a770-6e4d1a977fca",
              "label": "Photo of bound Palestinian detainee corroborates Israeli torture reports, say rights groups"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "challenges": [],
      "firings": [
        {
          "claimId": "a15c90a8-e78b-4c9d-a687-9130f6e63d48",
          "label": "The photo shows Osama, the son of Rana Abu Nasser.",
          "scheme": "expert-testimony",
          "version": "v1",
          "premises": [
            {
              "id": "e451f07d-7718-4c3a-b6d8-90fc17d74c11",
              "label": "Rana Abu Nasser says the photo shows her son Osama."
            }
          ],
          "criticalQuestions": [
            {
              "id": "523a1b5b-7cb4-420b-be2c-c0539239f88d",
              "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "ed134574-892d-44da-9f0a-143e11670605",
              "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "3db77de7-77eb-41c4-8a1d-ec129b004892",
              "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
              "status": "open"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "0c99bb07-120b-468f-93b4-096f0d874a0f",
          "label": "The photo shows Osama.",
          "scheme": "position-to-know",
          "version": "v1",
          "premises": [
            {
              "id": "e451f07d-7718-4c3a-b6d8-90fc17d74c11",
              "label": "Rana Abu Nasser says the photo shows her son Osama."
            }
          ],
          "criticalQuestions": [
            {
              "id": "ab54ec34-b7c0-4ed7-9dff-cc0868c13e35",
              "label": "Was the source actually positioned to observe or receive this?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "900c8e76-96e7-43c6-b8ad-44baa31ae393",
              "label": "Is the account corroborated by an independent source or artifact?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "f9952c59-f860-4a67-81a4-705fe7528bb3",
              "label": "Is the account a restatement of someone else’s, rather than first-hand?",
              "status": "open"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "worldsWith": 1,
      "worldsTotal": 3
    },
    {
      "claimId": "5ed37da5-8ca2-4ef7-8168-efe709f306ab",
      "label": "Joudeh al‑Ghoul says the photo shows her son Amin, missing since his arrest in November 2023.",
      "url": "/claim/joudeh-al-ghoul-says-the-photo-shows-her-son-amin-missing-since-his--5ed37da5",
      "share": 0.017705119240221837,
      "belief": 0.018,
      "dormant": true,
      "profile": {
        "cq": {
          "open": 0,
          "favorable": 0,
          "unfavorable": 0
        },
        "legs": 0,
        "shape": "challenged",
        "sources": 1,
        "challenges": 1,
        "restatements": 0,
        "contestedTime": false,
        "derivationDepth": 0,
        "supportingClaims": 0
      },
      "supports": [],
      "challenges": [
        {
          "claimId": "731bbc85-43e5-4759-8be4-1c3b4c957cb5",
          "label": "The Israeli military declined to comment on whether the detainee had been identified, received medical support, or if his family in Gaza had been notified.",
          "direction": "challenges",
          "supportKind": "circumstantial",
          "strength": "moderate",
          "assertionKind": null,
          "diagnostic": true,
          "sources": [
            {
              "id": "df50e329-62a9-455c-a770-6e4d1a977fca",
              "label": "Photo of bound Palestinian detainee corroborates Israeli torture reports, say rights groups"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "firings": [
        {
          "claimId": "b967b801-a061-4672-9ea3-570cc58ba4ed",
          "label": "The photo shows Amin, Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son.",
          "scheme": "expert-testimony",
          "version": "v1",
          "premises": [
            {
              "id": "5ed37da5-8ca2-4ef7-8168-efe709f306ab",
              "label": "Joudeh al‑Ghoul says the photo shows her son Amin, missing since his arrest in November 2023."
            }
          ],
          "criticalQuestions": [
            {
              "id": "fa8caf1c-42d9-4868-ab53-61e0aedd67af",
              "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "5abe786d-31f8-4e66-a786-3e1b11213e95",
              "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "f4f4e602-e685-4f1c-9f70-02c15645e808",
              "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
              "status": "open"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "claimId": "527d13a6-a602-4912-abe4-b5fcd6e21040",
          "label": "The photo shows Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son Amin.",
          "scheme": "position-to-know",
          "version": "v1",
          "premises": [
            {
              "id": "5ed37da5-8ca2-4ef7-8168-efe709f306ab",
              "label": "Joudeh al‑Ghoul says the photo shows her son Amin, missing since his arrest in November 2023."
            }
          ],
          "criticalQuestions": [
            {
              "id": "13695ea7-03b4-4ca8-8b57-6f5099662b6d",
              "label": "Was the source actually positioned to observe or receive this?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "9e58bd91-5d56-4e23-a935-15d491e57712",
              "label": "Is the account corroborated by an independent source or artifact?",
              "status": "open"
            },
            {
              "id": "e7d31f36-afa8-42e2-8368-e8afdcfbf596",
              "label": "Is the account a restatement of someone else’s, rather than first-hand?",
              "status": "open"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "worldsWith": 1,
      "worldsTotal": 3
    }
  ],
  "residual": {
    "share": 0.8649548767993755,
    "answers": 2,
    "spark": [
      0.865
    ]
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "df50e329-62a9-455c-a770-6e4d1a977fca",
      "kind": "source",
      "label": "Photo of bound Palestinian detainee corroborates Israeli torture reports, say rights groups"
    }
  ],
  "narratives": [
    {
      "rank": 1,
      "aggregateBelief": -0.1450779389607822,
      "selection": {
        "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6": null
      },
      "terms": [
        {
          "share": 0.8649548767993755,
          "choice": "(agnostic — left open)",
          "lnShare": -0.1450779389607822,
          "questionId": "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6",
          "questionLabel": "Who is the detainee shown in the photo?"
        }
      ],
      "prunedByNogood": [],
      "href": "/explore/who-is-the-detainee-shown-in-the-photo--52cd84ca?w="
    },
    {
      "rank": 2,
      "aggregateBelief": -2.14267954173291,
      "selection": {
        "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6": "c2ba1c85-5960-49e8-8ee2-fc43db4bc520"
      },
      "terms": [
        {
          "share": 0.11734000396040263,
          "choice": "Rana Abu Nasser says the photo shows her son Osama.",
          "lnShare": -2.14267954173291,
          "questionId": "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6",
          "questionLabel": "Who is the detainee shown in the photo?"
        }
      ],
      "prunedByNogood": [],
      "href": "/explore/who-is-the-detainee-shown-in-the-photo--52cd84ca?w=c2ba1c85"
    },
    {
      "rank": 3,
      "aggregateBelief": -4.0339014586077475,
      "selection": {
        "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6": "02c1ec9b-722c-4160-8cce-3462522694ae"
      },
      "terms": [
        {
          "share": 0.017705119240221837,
          "choice": "Joudeh al‑Ghoul says the photo shows her son Amin, missing since his arrest in November 2023.",
          "lnShare": -4.0339014586077475,
          "questionId": "52cd84ca-6eb6-4a97-a6b5-ccf278d721d6",
          "questionLabel": "Who is the detainee shown in the photo?"
        }
      ],
      "prunedByNogood": [],
      "href": "/explore/who-is-the-detainee-shown-in-the-photo--52cd84ca?w=02c1ec9b"
    }
  ],
  "openCriticalQuestions": [
    {
      "id": "523a1b5b-7cb4-420b-be2c-c0539239f88d",
      "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Osama, the son of Rana Abu Nasser.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "ed134574-892d-44da-9f0a-143e11670605",
      "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Osama, the son of Rana Abu Nasser.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "3db77de7-77eb-41c4-8a1d-ec129b004892",
      "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Osama, the son of Rana Abu Nasser.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "ab54ec34-b7c0-4ed7-9dff-cc0868c13e35",
      "label": "Was the source actually positioned to observe or receive this?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Osama.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "900c8e76-96e7-43c6-b8ad-44baa31ae393",
      "label": "Is the account corroborated by an independent source or artifact?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Osama.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "f9952c59-f860-4a67-81a4-705fe7528bb3",
      "label": "Is the account a restatement of someone else’s, rather than first-hand?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Osama.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "fa8caf1c-42d9-4868-ab53-61e0aedd67af",
      "label": "Is the source genuinely in a position to know?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Amin, Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "5abe786d-31f8-4e66-a786-3e1b11213e95",
      "label": "Is the claim independently corroborated?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Amin, Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "f4f4e602-e685-4f1c-9f70-02c15645e808",
      "label": "Does the source have an interest in this conclusion?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Amin, Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "13695ea7-03b4-4ca8-8b57-6f5099662b6d",
      "label": "Was the source actually positioned to observe or receive this?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son Amin.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "9e58bd91-5d56-4e23-a935-15d491e57712",
      "label": "Is the account corroborated by an independent source or artifact?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son Amin.",
      "inferences": 1
    },
    {
      "id": "e7d31f36-afa8-42e2-8368-e8afdcfbf596",
      "label": "Is the account a restatement of someone else’s, rather than first-hand?",
      "status": "open",
      "from": "The photo shows Joudeh al‑Ghoul's son Amin.",
      "inferences": 1
    }
  ],
  "honesty": "Shares are belief under the named lens, computed from evidence — never assigned. Quote the residual with the share; leading is not proven; repetition never moves a number."
}